Is F.I., S.I. – Socially Intelligent?
Against the backdrop of the fire and rage in Minneapolis following the police murder of George Floyd, reminiscent of police beating of Rodney King in LA in 1991, nearly 30 years ago, with many black deaths in between, what could possibly be the relationship of financial independence and the FIRE community to the unraveling in our society?
Are we quiescent on the edges, tending to our own business of careful managing of our money to reach financial independence? Are we concerned but powerless given our debts and gratitude for secure jobs we want to keep? Do we wonder what the connection might be between our brilliant strategy of buying our freedom through building capital and the unfair system that affords us the opportunity? Is the unrest close at hand for you or far away – and does that make a difference in how we respond?
The title of this post, FIRE in this time, keys off another era in the life of Black people in America. James Baldwin wrote Fire this Time. He said,”The brutality with which Negroes are treated in this country simply cannot be overstated, however unwilling white men may be to hear it,” The title was taken from a prophecy recreated from the Bible in a song of a slave:
“God gave Noah the rainbow sign,
No more water, the fire next time!”
Racism and injustice is the shadow of America, and it’s worthwhile to pause and take account of how our approach to money, called FIRE (financial independence retire early), may get us off the hook of a job, but not off the hook of being part of systems that rewards the already privileged and send disadvantaged to the margins.
Not your typical FI post
This is not your typical financial independence post, encouraging you to continue, giving your mental and practical tools for your own road to FI. Here I intend to pose to you the tough question I’ve asked myself for years: how does taking personal responsibility for our finances relate to the global economy’s preferential treatment of capital over people? In FI, we focus on personal responsibility; is social responsibility just not our thing?
Last Sunday I gave the keynote at the Virtual Camp Mustache titled “Are we just clever – or are we wise?”
In it I praised the brilliance of the Your Money or Your Life program in liberating individuals – myself included – and went on to ask: what is the shadow of this bright light?
Money is the life blood of a rigged system
I used this visual to explore that question.
The classic FI program helps you set up a system for observation of your daily life transactions, the emotions that arise from being stuck in the work and spend cycle, and the beliefs that drive us to accept that it’s the only money game we can play. Our feelings about our money lives can yoyo from elation (I just bought the thing I wanted) to despair (Idiot! You’ll never pay it off – or play with it). Our beliefs, drummed into us from all communication channels, are rooted in the basic mantra of society: More Is Better.
That’s where FI comes in. We pop out of that nightmare into a new dream, a dream of freedom, and doing what we want with our time. The steps of the program help us systematically unhook. We don’t struggle to adapt to the work and spend cycle, only a bit more peacefully. We jump ship, while using the advantages of the capitalist system we live in to buy sufficiency and security and freedom.
However, the book and the teaching only lightly touched on that capitalist system itself and on the impact of the design of money on life on earth.
Wising up about money
Where does More is Better come from? The economy’s imperative: Growth is Good.
It’s the demand of capital to turn a profit. Businesses need consumers. If the flow of consumption shuts down – as we are now seeing – they go under. Where does the imperative of growth come from? Some say, “Humans are greedy,” but I believe greed is just one way humans behave. We also share, love, prefer rest over work, value learning and relationships over the quest for more. I believe that the design of the money system encourages greed, even requires greed.
The right to issue money does not rest in the government. It rests in the Federal Reserve and its member banks. The Fed attempts to Goldilocks the economy – not too hot, not too cold, just right – through the prime rate, the interest banks pay on the money they borrow from the Fed and then turn around and lend – at a higher rate – to consumers. The US government authorizes the Fed, a private corporation, to run our money system. Banks do not have to have, in deposits, the money they lend to consumers. They only have to have 10% of that money in deposits, the rest is assumed to be created as people pay back their loans. This is called the Fractional Reserve. Money created this way is really a lien against future life energy – money – of the borrower. Some people end up indebted for life.
The last element that drives the Growth is Good imperative is the interest the banks charge on loans. Depending on the interest rate and the term of the loan, the borrower will need to come up with 2 or 3 times the original loan. The economy has to grow if borrowers are going to prosper enough to pay their loans with interest. Enough amateur economics – it’s just important to understand what money is at a systemic level. Class dismissed.
No system in nature grows forever. It’s juvenile – i.e. the characteristic of a body as it grows into maturity. Mature systems – trees, forests, species in ecological niches – grow in connections, not size. All mature systems are kept in balance by the give and take of animals, plants, sun, water, land, opportunities to flourish. A species that dominates a system without any predators to keep it in check will eventually eat through the easy and available energy (food) sources. The population will expand until all food is gone, and then collapse in numbers to restore the balance. Humans discovered the energy of the sun in the form of fossil fuels. While it looks like the sky is the limit, the market always goes up, are we reaching the end of our expansive economy? Much debate, but worthy of consideration.
Our economy treats the earth as “resources.” It assumes fungibility – if we run out of one resource, we can substitute another. You’re smart. You can see where that is headed.
Back to the Your Money or Your Life definition of money, now with the design of the money system and the finite earth in mind.
Money is something you choose to trade your life energy for. When you see how the work-and-spend cycle uses up your life, you choose conservative spending and building savings. You choose to live within the limits of your own life energy.
Where does the life energy freed up from earning money go?
I suggest you consider investing it – some, part or all – in building up a life energy account for the earth. What does that mean? Just about any form of service:
- Teaching FIRE to others to have ever more people spend ever less of the earth’s energy on stuff that makes no difference.
- Learning about investments that help reverse the cycle, broadly under the banner of ESG (environment, social and governance) commitments.
- Volunteering for causes you care about.
- Being involved in improving education
- Working on issues that benefit the essential workers – and humans – who do the hardest jobs for the smallest paycheck
- Innovating, innovating, innovating – using your skills and entrepreneurial spirit to build what is needed for a sustainable society, not a growth one.
- Parenting kids who “get it” – who have a thirst for service and sharp minds that can decode the messages of the consumer culture.
- Making your home a homestead with veggie garden and solar smart building and water harvesting and sharing.
- Working for justice. Being an ally to people who are on the streets – despite the pandemic – because their lives are so desperate.
And on and on and on. If you don’t need to earn money from how you spend your time, you can spend your time on some piece of making this work more safe, fair and free for all.
FIre is pro future
We conserve material resources by valuing enough and moderating consumption to just what we need.
We use our creativity and skills to maintain and fix what we have rather than toss and replace. Check out the Fix-it Clinic, created by FIer Peter Mui.
We have time enough to love. And to care about the future for all life, not just our own.
Duane Elgin, one of the grandfathers of our movement, quotes Richard Gregg in the opening of his book, Voluntary Simplicity, saying our purpose is to have a life that is “outwardly simple and inwardly rich.”
I know a lot of you are on this path or aspire to it. Perhaps the only next step needed is to aim higher and to wear your care for more than money like a badge of courage.
All is not lost if we lead.
While what we do with our time post FI is ours to choose, the backdrop of our lives is not. We live in a time of punishing racial and financial injustice. We live in a time when humans have driven hundreds of thousands of species into oblivion, and may be driving ourselves off the extinction cliff. The pandemic has denied tens of millions of people their income and along with it their health care. Black and brown people are dying at twice or more the rate of whites because racism makes being black or brown in this world is a pre-condition or vulnerability to the virus. So however we choose to spend our time, these realities are calling to us. What we do with our lives is our leadership, especially because people who’ve achieved FI are natural beacons for others. Where are you leading people? What is your beacon telling them about the responsibilities that come along with the right to retire? The protests this week mean that racism is now in all of our faces, is all of our business. The good thing – and there are many – is we have time enough to educate ourselves and act.
(Originally published May 29, 2020, on http://YourMoneyorYourLife.com)